Comments on dignified constitutional positions like the President and Governor are matters that deserve serious reflection - Vice President

Jagdeep Dhankhar today said, "I like challenges, and fulfilling constitutional obligations is our primary responsibility. No negligence in this regard can be accepted."

"A little while ago, I was told, 'You won't get [the book] for free either.' Your Excellency Governor Anandiben Patel, I don't have the habit of taking anything for free... The most dangerous challenge is the one that comes from within, which we cannot discuss... the challenge that comes from our own people, which has no logical basis, which has no connection with national development, which is related to governance. Not just you, I too am a victim of these challenges, Your Excellency Governor. I myself am a victim, a sufferer of these challenges. But we have a great strength before us, and our strength is our philosophy, which tells us that whenever a crisis arises, look towards the Vedas, look towards the Gita, Ramayana, Mahabharata - 'You have a right to perform your prescribed duties, but you are not entitled to the fruits of your actions.' Whenever challenges come, they will come. Challenges will come such that you feel helpless and think that even walls have ears. So you don't discuss that challenge even with yourself, but you must never deviate from the path of duty," he further said.

Speaking as the chief guest at the book launch event of 'I Like Challenges' by Honourable Governor Smt. Anandiben Patel in Lucknow today, he said, "People often say that public memory is short and think that over time, everything will be forgotten. But that's not the case. Have we forgotten the Emergency? Much time has passed, but the dark shadow of the Emergency is still visible to us today. It was the darkest period in Indian history when people were imprisoned without reason, access to the judiciary was obstructed. Fundamental rights disappeared, millions of people were thrown into jails. We haven't forgotten this. Similarly, regarding the painful incident that happened recently, I believe — and it is my firm conviction — that we must accept that every person is presumed innocent until proven guilty. In a democracy, innocence has a special significance. But whatever the crime may be, it must be resolved according to the law. And if a crime shakes the public conscience, it cannot be covered up. I have stated this with complete clarity. Some people asked me why I am so outspoken on this issue. I got a lot of inspiration from Her Excellency the Governor's book. And I have made it clear that I like challenges, and fulfilling constitutional obligations is our primary responsibility. No negligence in this regard can be accepted."

Expressing deep concern over comments made about constitutional positions, Shri Dhankhar said, "In our Constitution, two positions are considered supreme — one is the President of India, and the other is the Governor. And honourable Chief Minister, they are supreme because the oath you have taken, the oath I have taken, the oath that MPs, ministers, legislators, or any judge has taken — that oath is: I will uphold the Constitution. But Draupadi Murmu ji's (President) and Anandiben Patel ji's (Governor) oath is different from this. Their oath is: 'I will protect, preserve, and defend the Constitution.' And the second oath is: 'I will serve the people' — for the President, it's the people of India, and for the Governor, it's the people of the respective state. If comments are made on such dignified and constitutional positions, then according to me, it is a matter that deserves serious reflection."

Highlighting the importance of coordination and dialogue between all institutions created by the Constitution, the Vice-President emphasized, "In the last few days, an event has occurred, on which I have also issued a statement, and it is also connected to your state. I want to remind you that the biggest confrontation between the Legislature and the Judiciary happened in this very state. You are all well familiar with this subject. It is our paramount duty to ensure that our constitutional institutions respect each other, and this respect increases when each institution works within its own boundaries. When Institutions respect each other... our Constitution does not expect confrontation, but rather coordination, cooperation, dialogue, deliberation, and healthy debate. The Constitution does not envision conflict between institutions; it promotes a spirit of participation and balance."

In the same context, he further said, "All Institutions have their own roles. One should not play the role of another. We should respect the Constitution — literally, in spirit, and in essence, and I have said before, 140 crore people express their sentiments through elections, through their representatives, and those representatives reflect the public mind, and the public holds them accountable in elections. And that's why I have said in common man's language that just as the legislature cannot script a judgment, that is the court's job — similarly, the court cannot make laws.”

“I have the utmost respect for the judiciary; I have been a soldier of the judiciary. I spent more than four decades as a lawyer. Only in 2019, when I was appointed as the Governor of West Bengal, did I leave the practice of law. I know that there are extremely talented people in the judiciary. The judiciary is of great importance. How strong our democratic system is — is defined by the status of the judiciary. By global standards, our judges are among the best. But I appeal that we should show a spirit of cooperation, coordination, and participation. The executive, judiciary, and legislature — these institutions should work together and in harmony.", he added.

Emphasizing the importance of expression and debate in democracy, Shri Dhankhar said, "A very important point has been made, which is extremely necessary for all of us. Why do we call ourselves a democracy? Economic progress, development of institutional framework, expansion of technology — all these are important. But the real definition of democracy is — expression and debate. Expression and dialogue are the foundations of democracy. If there are restrictions on expression, it will be difficult for any nation to call itself democratic. But expression has no meaning if there is no debate with it. If expression reaches such an extent that the speaker thinks 'I am the only one who is right' and in all other circumstances, others are wrong, and there is no attempt to listen to them — then this is not the right to expression, but rather its distortion. Democracy is defined only when expression and dialogue flourish together in a comprehensive ecosystem. These two complement each other. And if expression reaches an extreme but there is no dialogue, then the philosophy of our Vedas — pluralism, will end. And in its place will be born 'ego and arrogance.' This 'ego and arrogance' are fatal for both individuals and institutions."

On this occasion, the Vice-President's spouse Smt. Sudesh Dhankhar, Honourable Governor of Uttar Pradesh Smt. Anandiben Patel, Honourable Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh Shri Yogi Adityanath, Cabinet Minister Shri Suresh Khanna, and other dignitaries were also present.